Reese’s Puffs PB+J Review
- Jordan Naeem
- 5 MIN CRUNCH
The opening bite
The first bite is loud. The puffs have that dense, full-volume Reese’s Puffs crunch, and they hold their shape all the way through the chew. Then the strawberry shows up, and this stops being a Reese’s Puffs variant and starts being a PB&J. The peanut butter is roasted and a little salty, the jelly is bright and jammy, and together they land exactly where a sandwich lands.
The strawberry pieces are the best part of the box. They taste like actual jelly, not strawberry-flavored sugar. As lifelong PB&J people, hats off to whoever in the General Mills flavor lab cracked this. The chocolate, meanwhile, brings nothing to the table. We’d never notice if it left.
The milk situation
This cereal is milk-proof. Our usual routine is to eat while we write the review, and somewhere along the way the bowl goes soggy and the flavor washes out. Not here. We wrote this entire review, came back to the bowl, and the puffs were almost exactly where we left them: crunchy, structurally sound, still tasting like PB&J. Nothing else we’ve reviewed comes close on bowl longevity.
The trade-off is the milk itself. Because the puffs refuse to give anything up, the milk barely changes. It picks up a little sweetness and not much else. It’s fine to drink. It’s not worth drinking on purpose.
That’s why this is one of the few cereals we like better dry. It still tastes great in milk, but out of the box the peanut butter and the strawberry are sharper and more distinct. Dry snackability: elite. This box is getting eaten by the handful.
Where it loses points
Milk transformation is the one category where this cereal doesn’t overachieve. The same armor that keeps the puffs crunchy for a whole review keeps the flavor locked inside them, so the milk at the bottom of the bowl is just slightly sweeter milk. That’s a 7.0, and it’s the main reason this box lands at 8.8 and misses the Hall of Crunch.
The other knock is a strange one: there’s barely any dust. Normally that’s a win. Here the dust is concentrated PB&J, and we wanted more of it. And the chocolate is dead weight.
The Good
- Stays crunchy through an entire review-length sitting
- Strawberry pieces taste like real jelly
- Better dry than in milk, which almost never happens
- Peanut butter and strawberry stay distinct, not muddy
The Criminal
- Milk barely transforms
- Chocolate brings nothing to the table
- So little dust we wanted more
Milk Takes
The verdict
An 8.8 for a cereal that scores 9.0 or better in four categories and is merely solid in milk. It slaps, and it slaps hardest straight from the box. SKIP THE MILK. EAT IT DRY.
The verdict
slaps
Crunch level
9.5
Flavor payload
9.0
Milk transformation
7.0
Bowl longevity
9.5
Dust situation
8.0
Dry Snackability
9.5
Box art
8.5
Jordan Naeem
if you ate that
You'll lose your mind over these
Kellogg's Strawberry-Sando
Strawberry-sando flakes 🇯🇵
Imagine a strawberry shortcake decided to have a sit-down meeting with corn flakes. The meeting went well.
Tue · Apr 28
4 min read
Kölln Crispy Chocolate & Biscuit
Kölln Crispy Chocolate & Biscuit
German Choco Krispies hit different. Bigger flakes, deeper chocolate, milk turns into a stein of cocoa.
Tue · Apr 28
4 min read
Taco Bell Cinnamon Twists Cereal
Yes, this exists. No, we are not okay.
A fast-food chain made a cereal. We had to. Tastes like a churro got into a fight with a Krave.
Tue · Apr 28
4 min read
Get one cereal review in your inbox every Tuesday.
No spam. No garbage cereals. Unsubscribe with one click.